Barnegat, NJ · Pizzeria & Italian Kitchen
Pizza and Italian favorites, made on Main Street.
Hand-stretched pies, gourmet pizzas, pasta, cheesesteaks, subs, wraps, and catering trays. Made to order at 580 North Main Street.
Takeout and delivery to Barnegat, Waretown, and Manahawkin.
- 18 Menu Categories
- Made to Order Every Pie
- Barnegat, NJ On Main Street
The Menu
What are you hungry for?
Welcome
A neighborhood kitchen with a serious menu
Pies on Main is where Barnegat comes for pizza night, pasta night, and everything in between. The menu runs deep: classic and gourmet pies, Sicilian squares, strombolis, wings, salads, entrées, and a full lineup of subs, wraps, and paninis. Whatever the table wants, it comes out hot and made to order.
If you know Pies on Nine South in Forked River, you already know this kitchen. Same family, same pies, new hometown.
Signatures
The pies people talk about
Start with the Grandma pie or go straight into the gourmet list. Rather keep it classic? Plain, white, and Sicilian pies are always on.
Catering
Feeding a crowd? That’s our thing.
Half and full trays, mix-and-match packages, sub boxes, and wrap platters. Office lunches, birthday parties, family gatherings. Tell us the headcount and we’ll take it from there.
- Half & full trays
- Sub & wrap boxes
- Serves 5 to 30+
Why Pies on Main
Built for the whole table.
A menu that goes deep
Eighteen categories, one kitchen. Everyone at the table finds their thing.
Made to order
Pies stretched and topped when you order, not before.
Catering that scales
From a sub box for five to trays for thirty-five.
Right on Main Street
Easy to find, easy to grab and go: 580 North Main.
Visit
Come find us
Bayshore Plaza, right on North Main Street.
Pies on Main
580 North Main StreetBarnegat, NJ 08005
Hours
- Monday Closed
- Tuesday Today 11:00 AM – 9:00 PM
- Wednesday 11:00 AM – 9:00 PM
- Thursday 11:00 AM – 9:00 PM
- Friday 11:00 AM – 10:00 PM
- Saturday 11:00 AM – 10:00 PM
- Sunday 11:00 AM – 9:00 PM
Dinner’s calling.
Browse the menu, plan a party, or just call it in.